After gracing the cover of Architectural Digest with her newly-remodeled, Beverly Hills bachelorette pad, Jennifer Aniston might not be as single as it seems.

In Cabo San Lucas, Mexico for a 41st birthday getaway, the former Friends star was seen with Friends gal pal Courteney Cox and other friends, including Sheryl Crow. But it was another fellow vacationer that has the magazines buzzing: Gerard Butler.

Even though the two kept their distance poolside to avoid the prying cameras, the Bounty Hunter co-stars further fueled the are-they-aren’t-they rumors.

Regardless, check out the pics of Jen in her bikini! We can only hope we look as good at 41…